Victimising and Trafficking in Human Beings

Blog by Mirco I. & Annika Z.

Human trafficking, a grave violation of human rights, continues to be a pressing global issue. This insidious crime involves the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring, or receipt of individuals through force, fraud, or deception, all with the sinister intent of exploiting them for profit. 

Victims of human trafficking come from diverse backgrounds, encompassing men, women, and children of all ages, making it an alarming and pervasive problem that knows no boundaries.

This abhorrent practice is not confined to any specific region, as it casts its ominous shadow over every part of the world. Traffickers employ various methods to ensnare their victims, often employing violence, fraudulent employment agencies, and deceptive promises of education and job opportunities. This manipulative strategy leaves victims vulnerable, coercing them into a life of exploitation.

Human trafficking is built upon three core elements: the act, the means, and the purpose. The traffickers utilize a spectrum of heinous tactics such as physical and sexual abuse, blackmail, emotional manipulation, and the confiscation of official documents to maintain control over their victims. This multi-faceted approach leaves victims trapped in an unending cycle of despair.

Exploitation is not limited to a specific geographical location. It can occur in a victim’s home country, during migration, or in a foreign land. Statistics reveal the grim reality, with the majority of cases falling into the following categories: 38.8% forced labour, 38.7% sexual exploitation, 10.3% mixed forms of exploitation, 10.2% linked to criminal activities, 0.9% forced marriages, 0.7% begging, 0.3% baby selling, and 0.2% organ removal. These figures underscore the severity of the problem and the diverse ways in which human lives are cruelly exploited.

In this short blog, we will have a deeper look into human trafficking in Germany and will compare it with a country of the global south, Bangladesh. 

It is important to have a basic overview about this topic and to raise awareness. Human Trafficking in Germany: A Growing Concern Amidst Pandemic Challenges the Federal Situation Report of 2022 provides a stark overview of the human trafficking situation in Germany.
Notably, the report highlights a concerning rise in human trafficking cases, particularly for sexual exploitation, labour exploitation, and exploitation of minors. The figures reveal 346 cases related to sexual exploitation, 34 cases connected to labour exploitation, and a striking 171 cases involving the exploitation of minors. It is essential to note that the number of victims often surpasses the number of reported cases, emphasizing the hidden nature of this crime.

The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic triggered a noticeable increase in human trafficking cases. This shift is attributed to the transformation of traditional prostitution settings, such as bars and brothels, into more discreet forms, like apartment-based prostitution and house or hotel visits. The pandemic-related restrictions in the prostitution industry gradually eased in 2022, contributing to the surge in sexual exploitation cases. 

Human trafficking and labour exploitation are covert crimes that often go unreported. Victims frequently avoid seeking help or disclosing their situation due to various reasons, including fear of authorities or perpetrators, social isolation, uncertain immigration status, pressure to work off debts, and even a lack of awareness that they are victims of trafficking.

In the realm of human trafficking for sexual exploitation, the report notes a significant increase in cases compared to the previous year. The trend of shifting away from traditional street-based prostitution towards more discreet and less regulated forms continued throughout the reporting year. Victims primarily consisted of individuals from Eastern Europe, and notably, an increasing number from Asian countries such as China, Thailand, and Vietnam.

Perpetrators of human trafficking and exploitation typically operate internationally. Consequently, strengthening international law enforcement cooperation is imperative in combatting this complex criminal network. Additionally, a successful fight against human trafficking and exploitation necessitates multidisciplinary collaboration among all relevant stakeholders, including law enforcement agencies, the justice system, non-governmental organizations, and counselling centres.

Only by working together can we address the challenges posed by human trafficking and offer effective support to its victims. In Human Trafficking in Bangladesh and Germany: A Comparative Perspective as of September 2021, the Bangladeshi government had reported over 5,000 pending trafficking cases awaiting investigation or prosecution. NGOs and international organizations, on the other hand, identified a disheartening number of victims in the country.
At least 580 cases of sex trafficking victims, 6,378 labour trafficking victims, and 717 victims of unspecified exploitation were reported. 

The diversity among these victims is striking: sex trafficking included 429 women, 10 men, 111 female children, 10 male children, and 20 LGBTQI+ individuals. Labor trafficking victims comprised 4,328 men, 1,902 women, 93 female children, 41 male children, and 14 LGBTQI+ individuals.

Bangladesh stands out as one of the countries significantly affected by labour migration. Official figures indicate that approximately 5 million Bangladeshis work abroad, but unofficial estimates suggest that this number might be as high as 12 million. The dire living conditions drive many to leave their homeland in search of a better life. 

Migration is often seen as an opportunity to secure a basic level of education and healthcare for their families, but the majority are unaware of the risks and dangers involved. Many migrants lack knowledge of their rights, are often unable to speak the language of their destination country, and thus rely on intermediaries who, more often than not, prioritize their own interests. In this context, migrants become commodities without a voice or rights.

In comparison, Germany might have more advanced laws and a stronger enforcement of anti-human trafficking measures. This potentially means that Germany is better equipped to detect, combat, and prosecute human trafficking cases. Germany also grapples with one of the highest migration rates in Europe, rendering it more susceptible to human trafficking cases, particularly related to sexual exploitation and forced labour. 

Conversely, Bangladesh’s internal migration and the influx of refugees from neighbouring countries pose an increased risk of internal human trafficking cases.
It is important to recognize that human trafficking is a multifaceted issue influenced by various factors. 

Both Germany and Bangladesh are actively working at national and international levels to combat human trafficking and protect victims. Efforts to raise awareness, improve law enforcement, and provide support to survivors are ongoing in both countries.

 
In conclusion, while the scale and nature of human trafficking differ between Bangladesh and Germany, the fight against this crime is a shared global responsibility. Efforts to prevent trafficking, protect victims, and prosecute perpetrators must continue, regardless of the specific challenges each country faces. 

Measures to Combat Human Trafficking by the United Nations (UN) plays a pivotal role in the global fight against human trafficking by implementing a comprehensive approach that encompasses research, awareness, and international cooperation. This multifaceted strategy comprises several critical actions.

One of the fundamental steps undertaken by the UN is the delivery of expertise to its member states. By offering guidance, support, and best practices, the UN assists nations in their efforts to combat human trafficking effectively. The organization recognizes the importance of investing in people, particularly those who have fallen victim to trafficking. Vulnerable individuals are provided with protection and support to help them recover from their traumatic experiences.

Moreover, the UN ensures that member states are equipped with the necessary legal and operational tools to address and prosecute human trafficking cases. This not only involves the development of legal frameworks but also extends to the provision of resources and training for law enforcement and judicial authorities. A critical aspect of the UN’s approach is building networks among member states and civil society. 

Collaboration is seen as a key factor in strengthening the global response to human trafficking. By fostering international cooperation and information sharing, the UN creates a unified front against this criminal activity. At the core of international efforts is the Palermo Protocol, which stands as the most widely adopted international agreement aimed at combatting human trafficking. Currently, 181 countries are parties to this protocol, with 117 having both signed and ratified it, rendering it legally binding.

To facilitate and monitor the implementation of the Palermo Protocol, a review mechanism has been established. Under this framework, states mutually assess each other’s efforts in combatting human trafficking. Germany, for instance, began its review process on March 1, 2023, with Suriname and Canada serving as reviewing states. 

In reciprocation, Germany is conducting reviews of Luxembourg, the United States, and Djibouti. The involvement of relevant ministries, such as the Federal Ministry for Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women, and Youth, in overseeing and supporting the review process underscores the commitment of the international community to addressing human trafficking comprehensively.

In essence, the UN’s proactive and collaborative approach highlights the importance of research, awareness, and international cooperation as fundamental tools in the ongoing battle against human trafficking.

Sources:

https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/human-Trafficking/Human-Trafficking.html

https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-andanalysis/glotip/2022/GLOTiP_2022_chapter_1_Global_Overview_230123.pdf

https://www.kok-gegenmenschenhandel.de/fileadmin/user_upload/medien/Publikationen_KOK/KOKDatenbericht_2022_web_final.pdf

https://www.bka.de/DE/AktuelleInformationen/StatistikenLagebilder/Lagebilder/Menschenhandel/menschenhandel_node.html

https://www.unodc.org/documents/overview.pd

 https://www.bka.de/DE/UnsereAufgaben/Deliktsbereiche/Menschenhandel/menschenhandel_nod e.html

https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-trafficking-in-persons-report/bangladesh/

https://www.bmfsfj.de/bmfsfj/themen/gleichstellung/frauen-vor-gewalt-schuetzen/bekaempfungdes-menschenhandels-auf-internationaler-ebene’ 


Partners

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top